Super Kosher (Chalav Yisrael) Cheeses Skip to content
This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Monthly subscriptions on individual cheeses are now available. Select the subscription from the product page and head to checkout!

The Cheese Guy logo features the words 'the CHEESE guy' in a stylized serif font, with the tagline 'artisanal small-batch' below. A cheese wedge graphic is positioned above the text. The logo is dark gray on a transparent background.
The Cheese Guy logo features the words 'the CHEESE guy' in a stylized serif font, with the tagline 'artisanal small-batch' below. A cheese wedge graphic is positioned above the text. The logo is dark gray on a transparent background.

  • Home
  • Our Products
    • All Products
    • Current Online Selection
  • Our Collections
    • Curated Cheese Subscription
    • Platters and Baskets
    • Aged or Hard Cheese
    • Bulk (Food Service) Size
    • Cheese Accompaniments
    • Goat and Sheep Milk Cheese
    • Imported Cheese
    • Lactose-Free Cheese
    • New England Collection
    • Passover Kosher Certified
    • Raw Milk Cheese
    • Super Kosher Cheese
    • Sustainable (Ugly 😜) Cheese Boxes
    • Merch
    • Gift Cards
  • Events
    • Book an Event
    • Events Calendar
  • Farmers Markets
  • About
    • About Us
    • Our Mission
    • Testimonials
    • FAQs
    • Gallery
    • News and Blogs
  • Store Locator
Search
  • Home
  • Our Products
    • All Products
    • Current Online Selection
  • Our Collections
    • Curated Cheese Subscription
    • Platters and Baskets
    • Aged or Hard Cheese
    • Bulk (Food Service) Size
    • Cheese Accompaniments
    • Goat and Sheep Milk Cheese
    • Imported Cheese
    • Lactose-Free Cheese
    • New England Collection
    • Passover Kosher Certified
    • Raw Milk Cheese
    • Super Kosher Cheese
    • Sustainable (Ugly 😜) Cheese Boxes
    • Merch
    • Gift Cards
  • Events
    • Book an Event
    • Events Calendar
  • Farmers Markets
  • About
    • About Us
    • Our Mission
    • Testimonials
    • FAQs
    • Gallery
    • News and Blogs
  • Store Locator
  • Log in
  • Search
Overhead view of a cheese board with cheese, grapes, crackers, honey, and breadsticks on a wooden table.

Super Kosher (Chalav Yisrael) Cheeses

Super Kosher (Chalav Yisrael) Cheeses - over 30 varieties of premium quality cheeses never available in the marketplace before......from pungent French cheeses to sharp Italian Pecorino Romano, 1 yr aged Parmesan, Vermont artisan cheddars, fresh goat cheeses, creamy Italian burrata and everyday jack cheeses and more.

Availability
Price
 
 
 
$
-
$
Home/Collections/Super Kosher (Chalav Yisrael) Cheeses
  • Featured
  • Most relevant
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old
Parmesan, Shredded
Quick View

Parmesan, Shredded CY

$12.00

Image of The Cheese Guy Pecorino al Pepe Nero, a light-colored wedge-shaped block of sheep's milk cheese with black peppercorns, showing the brand logo and 'Pecorino al Pepe Nero (Black Pepper)' product name on the label.
Image of The Cheese Guy Pecorino al Pepe Nero, a light-colored wedge-shaped block of sheep's milk cheese with black peppercorns on an orange background, showing the brand logo and 'Pecorino al Pepe Nero (Black Pepper)' product name on the label.
Quick View

Pecorino al Pepe Nero (Black Pepper)

$18.00

A wedge of The Cheese Guy Pecorino al Tartufo cheese features a circular black and orange label with the product name in bold letters, indicating it's made from grass-fed sheep and is vegetarian, with visible black truffle pieces throughout the cheese.
A wedge of The Cheese Guy Pecorino al Tartufo cheese, featuring a circular black and orange label with the product name in bold letters, indicating it's made from grass-fed sheep and is vegetarian, with visible black truffle pieces throughout the cheese, against a dark grey background.
Quick View

Pecorino al Tartufo

$18.00

A wedge of The Cheese Guy Pecorino Romano cheese, featuring an orange and black label with the product name "PECORINO ROMANO" in bold letters, indicating it's made from grass-fed sheep, vegetarian, naturally lactose-free, and aged 12 months.
Overhead shot of ingredients for making pizza, featuring a wedge of The Cheese Guy Organic Pecorino Romano cheese with its label visible, a pile of shredded cheese, a partially visible block of cheese, sliced red onions, a whole white onion, and a rectangular flatbread pizza topped with sauce, cheese, mushrooms, red peppers, and red onions, all arranged on a dark grey surface with a wooden pizza peel handle and a white patterned cloth partially visible.
Quick View

Pecorino Romano

$18.00

Image of The Cheese Guy Smoked Provolone, a round cheese with a distinctive orange label, showing the brand logo, product name, and 'Grass Fed,' 'Vegetarian,' and 'Gluten Free' attributes.
Image of The Cheese Guy Smoked Provolone, round cheese with a distinctive orange label, displayed on a cheese board with various accompaniments including crackers, oranges, blackberries, pomegranate, honey, nuts, and wine.
Quick View

Provolone Smoked

$16.00

Stuzzichine Fresh Mozzarella (small balls)
Stuzzichine Fresh Mozzarella (small balls)
Only Available In Store
Quick View

Stuzzichine Fresh Mozzarella (small balls)

$13.00

Image of a triangular wedge of Swiss cheese, showing its distinctive holes, resting on a textured wooden surface.
Temporarily Out of Stock
Quick View

Swiss, Lacey Baby

$14.00

Image of The Cheese Guy Tilsit, a light-colored rectangular block of cheese, showing the brand logo and 'Tilsit' product name on the label.
Image of The Cheese Guy Tilsit, a light-colored rectangular block of cheese on an orange background, showing the brand logo and 'Tilsit' product name on the label.
Quick View

Tilsit

$15.00

A wedge of The Cheese Guy Viney Sheep cheese, aged over 9 months in red wine, featuring a circular orange and black label with the product name in bold pink letters, indicating it's made from grass-fed sheep, vegetarian, and naturally lactose-free.
A triangular wedge of aged, hard cheese, likely Parmesan or Pecorino Romano, with a slightly darker rind resting on a rough, textured grey surface.
Quick View

Viney Sheep, Pecorino

$16.00

The Cheese Guy

EXPLORE

  • Home
  • Our Cheese
  • Our Collection
  • Search
  • Sitemap
  • Store Locator
  • Product Catalog

ENGAGE

  • Blogs
  • Book An Events
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Upcoming Events

CONNECT WITH US

718-698-5154

info@thecheeseguy.com

JOIN OUR CHEESE CLUB!

Join our cheese-loving community for exclusive offers, fresh updates, and tasty recipes

Email is invalid or already taken.
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa
  • Instagram
  • Facebook

Currency

  • Canada Canada (CAD $)
  • United States United States (USD $)

© 2026, The Cheese Guy

Powered by Shopify

Close