This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Overhead shot of two white goat cheese logs with dark flecks on a square wooden plate, garnished with parsley, alongside a garlic bulb and cloves, with parsley sprigs, on a light wooden surface.

Goat and Sheep Milk Cheese Collection

Crafted from the milk of small farm goats, our mozzarella emerges as a delight—light, velvety, and mildly nuanced, akin to the classic rendition but with a touch more firmness. On the other side of our artisanal spectrum lies the Goat Cheddar, aged patiently for over 6 months, born from non-animal rennet and the richness of unpasteurized goat's milk. This cheddar boasts a distinct character, a symphony of grassy and herbaceous notes that dance on the palate. Whether you slice, snack, or melt, indulge in a culinary journey where each bite reveals the essence of goat's milk mastery.

Overhead shot of a wooden plate featuring two bagel halves spread with The Cheese Guy Fresh & Creamy Goat Cheese and topped with sprouts, accompanied by a package of the same goat cheese, a small wooden honey dipper with a drizzle of honey, a glass of yellow liquid with a lime wedge, a folded orange cloth napkin, and green leaves.

Quick View

Goat Cheese w/ Cranberry-Cinnamon

$7.00

Overhead shot of two logs of white goat cheese with dark flecks, garnished with fresh parsley, on a square wooden plate, accompanied by a whole bulb of garlic, several individual garlic cloves, and additional sprigs of parsley, arranged on a light-colored wooden surface.

Quick View

Goat Cheese w/ Garlic & Herb

$7.00

Overhead shot of a spinach and beet salad in a white bowl featuring baby spinach, crumbled goat cheese, sliced roasted beets, and slivered almonds, accompanied by a package of The Cheese Guy Fresh & Creamy Goat Cheese with Honey, a wooden slotted spoon, roasted beets with their stems, slices of bread, and a log of goat cheese with two slices, all arranged on a light blue surface with a folded yellow cloth napkin.

Quick View

Goat Cheese w/ Honey

$7.00

Overhead shot of a spinach and beet salad in a white bowl with crumbled goat cheese and almonds, accompanied by a container of The Cheese Guy Fresh & Creamy Goat Cheese Crumbles, a log of goat cheese being sliced with a knife, a wooden slotted spoon, and slices of bread, all arranged on a light blue surface with a folded yellow cloth napkin.

Only Available in Stores

Quick View

Goat Cheese, Crumbled

$6.00

A close-up of a small orange bowl filled with mixed green and black olives, some stuffed with pimentos, next to a log of white goat cheese and several slices on a light-colored wooden board, garnished with fresh parsley leaves.

Only Available in Stores

Quick View

Goat Cheese, Plain

From $6.50

Overhead shot of a white plate containing a burrata salad with a creamy white burrata cheese ball, red and yellow cherry tomatoes, green herbs, and black pepper, positioned next to a beige napkin with a fork and knife, and the base of a wine glass, all on a dark wooden surface.

Only Available in Stores

Quick View

Goat Mozzarella

$13.00

Quick View

Goat Muenster, CY-P

$13.00

A wedge of The Cheese Guy Spanish Collection Manchego P.D.O. cheese, aged 4 months, made from sheep milk. The circular label states it's "Chalav Yisrael, Kosher for Passover and Year Round" and is prominently displayed on the rich yellow cheese.

A wedge of The Cheese Guy Spanish Collection Manchego P.D.O. cheese, aged 4 months, made from sheep milk. The circular label states it's "Chalav Yisrael, Kosher for Passover and Year Round" and is prominently displayed on the rich yellow cheese on a blue background.

Quick View

Manchego, 4-month-aged

$18.00

A wedge of The Cheese Guy Pecorino al Tartufo cheese features a circular black and orange label with the product name in bold letters, indicating it's made from grass-fed sheep and is vegetarian, with visible black truffle pieces throughout the cheese.

A wedge of The Cheese Guy Pecorino al Tartufo cheese, featuring a circular black and orange label with the product name in bold letters, indicating it's made from grass-fed sheep and is vegetarian, with visible black truffle pieces throughout the cheese, against a dark grey background.

Quick View

Pecorino al Tartufo

$18.00

A wedge of The Cheese Guy Pecorino Romano cheese, featuring an orange and black label with the product name "PECORINO ROMANO" in bold letters, indicating it's made from grass-fed sheep, vegetarian, naturally lactose-free, and aged 12 months.

Overhead shot of ingredients for making pizza, featuring a wedge of The Cheese Guy Organic Pecorino Romano cheese with its label visible, a pile of shredded cheese, a partially visible block of cheese, sliced red onions, a whole white onion, and a rectangular flatbread pizza topped with sauce, cheese, mushrooms, red peppers, and red onions, all arranged on a dark grey surface with a wooden pizza peel handle and a white patterned cloth partially visible.

Quick View

Pecorino Romano

$18.00

A wedge of The Cheese Guy Ricotta Salata cheese features a circular black and orange label with the product name in bold green letters, indicating it's made from grass-fed sheep and is vegetarian.

Overhead shot of a bowl of pasta with tomato sauce, basil, and grated cheese, accompanied by a wedge of The Cheese Guy Ricotta Salata, a bunch of fresh tomatoes on the vine, loose basil leaves, a bowl of grated cheese, and a striped cloth napkin, all arranged on a light grey wooden surface.

Only Available in Stores

Quick View

Ricotta Salata

$16.00

A wedge of The Cheese Guy Viney Sheep cheese, aged over 9 months in red wine, featuring a circular orange and black label with the product name in bold pink letters, indicating it's made from grass-fed sheep, vegetarian, and naturally lactose-free.

A triangular wedge of aged, hard cheese, likely Parmesan or Pecorino Romano, with a slightly darker rind resting on a rough, textured grey surface.

Quick View

Viney Sheep, Pecorino

$16.00